Refutation of Shia Belief

-

 As per shia belief giving power (Sultah) to someone who is not from Ahlul Bayt or someone who is a criminal and a tyrant is a huge sin (tbh lowkey impossible as they call their Imams angels)


“مشهورا بالعلم، والاجتهاد، والورع… ومنابذة أعداء الله الظالمين… والرأفة والرحمة… فإذا كان مشهورا بذلك… وجبت طاعته”


(Majmūʿ al-Imām al-Qāsim b. Muḥammad 1/284)


“الجامع… الهادي… الناهض بنشر أعلام الشريعة” 

(Al-Imām al-Ṣādiq 1/64)


"If Muʿāwiyah were (God forbid) a kafir, sinful tyrant, or unjust usurper, then the blame would fall upon Imam Hasan for entrusting the affairs of the Muslims to such a person willingly and without compulsion." 


(IARK said this) 


hadith from bukhari: “This son of mine is a leader, and Allah will reconcile through him two great groups of Muslims.”


 If he was a tyrant or a kafir then this hadith is proving that rafidi belief wrong because the words are pretty clear here both groups are muslim groups And even as per sh'ites this would have been a great sin transfering power to Muawiiyah if he was wrong then Imam Hasan commited a grave sin by their own sources and handed over leadership to someone who is not from Ahlul Bayt.

There are authentic reports that every year Muawiiyah (RA) would give alot of presents to both of them (Hasan and Husayn)

So why were they taking gifts from a kafir or immoral person then?

All this stuff is sinful as per the shi'ites

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Question and answer regarding something

-
 The Question Zaid claims: Apart from having a Leader (Peshwa) and a Sheikh, counting the rosary (Tasbeeh) and reciting Salawat (Durood) or litanies (Wazifa) is equivalent to wasting one’s life. Bakr states: "I am not pledged (Bay'ah) to any person. I pray, I fast, and I accept the rulings of the Noble Shariah, the Glorious Quran, and whatever the Scholars of Religion say as the truth. However, I am not a disciple (Mureed) of any specific Peer or Faqir, though I do not consider becoming a disciple as something bad." The Conflict: According to Zaid’s statement, in this scenario, no worship of any kind performed by Bakr is accepted in the Court of the Almighty. All of Bakr’s worship is wasted because he is without a disciplehood. Greeting Bakr is deemed impermissible, he is considered expelled from the circle of Islam, and he will be resurrected with the faction of devils. In this situation, what should Bakr do? The Answer The Sheikh—meaning the Murshid (Spiritual Guide), t...
Read more

Iʿlām al-muwaqqiʿīn ʿan rabb al-ʿālamīn (311)

-
Shaykh Al Islam Ibn Qayyim (RA) said: "A large heart can contain great knowledge just as a large valley can hold a large amount of water; and a small heart can contain knowledge only in proportion to its capacity, just as a small valley holds a small amount of water. The valleys flow according to their size, and hearts receive guidance and knowledge according to their capacity. Just as when the floodwater mixes with the earth and passes over it, it carries with it chaff and foam, so too does guidance and knowledge, when mixed with the hearts, stir up the desires and doubts therein to uproot and remove them. This is like medicine which, when drunk, stirs up the humors (akhlaṭ) of the body, causing the drinker to feel discomfort for a while."
Read more

The Definition of Fiṭrah. Is Fiṭrah Islam?

-
Fiṭrah ≠ fully-formed Islamic creed. Fiṭrah = an innate disposition toward tawḥīd, recognition of a Creator, and basic moral truths. The Holy Prophet ﷺ said: “Every child is born upon the fiṭrah, but it is his parents who make him a Jew, Christian, or Magian.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim) Imam Ghazali (rh) said: “Fitrah inclines toward affirmation, but without proof it may also incline toward falsehood. Thus proofs are necessary to separate truth from falsehood.” The fiṭrah gives them the innate pull toward tawḥīd. The revelation tells them how to worship properly, who Allah truly is, and what false beliefs to reject. Without revelation, fiṭrah could lead someone to vague deism, sun worship, or pantheism. That’s why the Qur’an criticizes the mushrikīn for their wrong acts man, And regarding this fitrah argument this comes in my mind: If Muslims are only upon fiṭrah, then what’s the need for Qur’an, Sunnah, and Prophets? Are Hindus and Christians also valid if they claim their fiṭrah led them to the...
Read more